BoursoBank RIP / Change Bank ASAP

Hi Everyone,

For some of you who had issues doing the first login on a phone saying that the app was not downloaded from the play store, the trick was to freeze temporary GMS (either MIcroG companion or Play Framework) and connect.

Since the end of August, Boursorama seems to have enforced that and no login can be bypassed by this method if the app does not receive the appropriate answer from play store even on a phone with Google services.

I am very sure it is not something e Fondation can solve as is would be solving Play Integrity for Gogglelized phones that are not certified.

It is very clear that boursorama is fully linked with google and do not plan to do without it. I think we need to boycott this bank and look for an alternative that does not use google at all for payments.

More ethical banks exist. We should propably enjoy the opportunity they gladly offered us to do so !

Recent European laws and this fact shows us that they really plan on controling us even more. We need to be very carefull and exclude any company that go in that direction !

2 Likes

There is no “PlayStore” only App Lounge, log in with anonymous mode is the best recommendation, you trying to move away from Google with eOS.

1 Like

Is the app the only way to access/manage your account with boursobank? Cannot you just use the browser access login and forget the app?

I use two U.K. banks and never bothered with their apps, just login through mobile browser in mobile mode (versus desktop one) and get a mobile look of their banking (mobile friendly) that feels like app but is not.

Have you checked that ’route’ with boursobank?

1 Like

Totally agree with you.

If one likes this bank he can still use it without the app by simply connecting through the website.

Otherwise as you said, we can boycott such companies, this helps putting market pressure on them so that they will remove this constraint. It is especially problematic when some piece of hardware like a car needs an app and google safety check to run. Even worse, when the app stops being maintained (and it will) the hardware becomes unusable! This has become more and more frequent.

The other axis to change the situation is to contact EU commission and our EU member of parliament to give them another example and speed up the enforcement of existing regulations that already rule against the closure of systems by gate-keepers.

1 Like

Please read the original post before answering.

@GabrielT I did read it the OP’s says

key word play store? I open App Lounge found the app Boursorama (banking app) and installed it on my phone in anonymous mode. I am suggesting OP does it the same way.

The bank app does open for me on my phone running a16eOS3.7.. I obliviously can’t open the account as I don’t have one but I had zero issues installing it from App Lounge.

Hi @Jets
Installing it works fine, but when you try to log in, either it doesn’t work or you get a message saying that the app wasn’t installed via the Google Play Store.

2 Likes

Otherwise, we would need to lodge a complaint with the Banking Ombudsman, or take legal action, or bring the matter before the European Commission to highlight this issue.

I’m all for it, because at no point does BB state that its app (and therefore the BB account) only works with Google or Apple.

Still perfectly working on my side on 4.2 / fp5 / unlocked bootloader. Noticeable in my microg options:

  • real profile
  • Droiguard hardware validation disabled - in certification advanced options
  • Hidden applications set to automatic, worth trying in manual mode

Since my phone is not yet registered as a trusted device, I receive an email saying “a new device has been connected to my account” each time I try. But each time, the animation keeps running and the phone is never connected.

1 Like

Salut Chris, as-tu trouvé une solution à ce problème ? je viens de passer sous Murena, et quand j’ai fait mes recherches avant d’opter pour ça j’avais vu que Boursobank fonctionnait mais en effet ça ne marche pas

Thank you for your suggestion @Telcoced. Just tryed on FP6 /e/OS 4.2, bootloader locked with your parameters. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work.:frowning:

1 Like

As grzecel said, use the website site from a web browser, it works as well as the app without the trackers and safety checks issues . You can even use a shortcut on your main screen launcher and you won’t be able to tell the difference between the native app and the web-browser shortcut !

In general it is better not to use an app when the website offers the exact same functionalities. Mostly because of trackers. That is why most company push the user to use the app when you are on the website…

Some banks impose the use of their app as a device-passkey/authentication-signature, in this case you cannot bypass the app use. But this is not the case with Bourso Bank, you can still connect with SMS and email 3 factors authentication. In that regard, boursobank respects the customer as they offer ways not to use google or apple.

In the case of banks that impose the app as an authentication method, they usually also offer other methods like a separate electronic device that can read your credit card id and use that as a hardware-passkey (signature encrypted with a private key) that generates authentication codes to access the banking website without having to go to the bank office.

2 Likes

Thank you for your answer but what about the payment system, usually we have to accept the payment by the app. How does it work if we don’t have it ?

It asks you to validate it through an SMS and an email.

I guess that either the law says that the system must be open or that simply the company wants to avoid annoying its customer and therefore allows another way than an app.

1 Like

Also nothing if rebooting after applying those settings?

A bug report is open Here for this issue. You can add some details if you want for the developers.

1 Like

Unfortunately no. Even shutting down the device.

It will still work if your device is registered. It will not work if you try to register the device since mid August. Do not delete the app or reset your phone otherwise you loose it !

As Gabriel T points out, the shortcut on the home screen works… I’ve been using this for two years with /e/Os (account management, payment, transfers…). Authentication is done by double code SMS and e.mail. The only option I haven’t managed to get is to pay by card stored on the mobile via NFC… Sincerely,