Does anyone know what the rationale was for including this in the UI? I realise it seems both odd to look so deeply into something like this - which may not have any particular rationale behind it and might just be trend-following - and to question something that seems like it could only be a positive thing, but there are a few reasons I don’t like these kinds of elements:
They are often overly cutesy IMO
They are an example, however innocuous, of the device telling the user what to do as opposed to the other way around
It seems inappropriate for the phone’s UI to not be neutral regarding the kind content the user writes on it. Having UI elements that include a value judgment is inherently distracting to me - the UI should just be there to inform the user about the state and available actions in the app.
Since the phone isn’t actually intelligent and the message is fixed, there will be contexts in which the message is inappropriate for a whole range of different reasons
Hello.
100% agreeing on this, and more … like on anything else that these machines :
propose without any request from me (just like advertising does in RL),
enforce me to do by default, because the developer of the app/service did a wrong choice about the default setting, or ergonomics, and the app / service does not save user settings (ex with Android 10: force-disable the “extreme battery energy saver” when the phone is charged, force-enable the “fast charging” mode at boot time, force a swipe up gesture to get to the desktop when awaking the phone even when there’s no “session” pass code, …),
prevent me from doing for security reasons (“security” : a work that’s used to justify any stupidity), like (Android 10, most browsers) open a local HTML file in a browser though a simple and “standard” file:// URL (rather than forcing to go though a system / app service that generates a temporary URL that works … but that you can’t bookmark …).
I simply want to do my own choices (the device is mine, I want to use it the way I want) and the machine / device to wait for my requests.
Probably old fashioned, by the way.