Hello,
here is my little experience with /e/ on two devices. Redmi Note 4 and Pocophone F1.
First of all, thanks a lot for all the team for your work on this great project.
I hope that /e/ will become a must to have in doing without GAFAM.
Context :
I never had smartphone before I discovered the /e/ project because I don’t want to give all my data to GAFAM.
At home, I have selfhosted apps on raspberry pi for, cloud, dns, secrets, etc.
I started to use /e/ 6 month ago.
As the project seems to be a good idea, I decided to buy a device from the compatibility list to test if it could be compatible with my life without google, facebook, etc
I bought a Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 to begin and I was seduced by /e/. I started with version 0.1 on it.
The only things I didn’t want to do was to open some “e accounts”, I want using a smartphone without any specific account except for the accounts I manage at home.
So I installed a Baikal server for my contacts and Calendar, Turtl for share Documents/pictures with my family, I already had a cloud with Seafile and I tested Owntrack successfully.
Calls are OK, no problems with SMS, bluetooth works with : my PC, my rapsberry media server, my radio in car.
I can make calls with bluetooth in my car, I can use GPS and Magic Earth to navigate, (sometimes GPS takes time to hang a satellite, but in general, it’s okay.)
photos are in good quality, I can surf on web with the default browser or the Tor browser, I can read my webmail, I can play music, pilot my drone and play games.
The update system is OK.
So /e/ is fully usable on my Redmi Note 4.
It’s compatible with my life without GAFAM and my desires for modernity. I decided to use it as main phone.
I use Apkpure and F-Droid as stores.
I disable for most apps the registration in microG.
I apply Privacy Guard by default to new apps.
I don’t want to have to root my phone.
I don’t use finger sensor, pattern is enough for me.
I use profiles, this is a great feature ! So in the morning, when I leave home, the bluetooth turns on, the bluetooth connection with the car is automatic and when I arrive at work, the bluetooth is turned off and the wifi is automaticaly turn on. And so on when I leave work.
I encountered some problems in version 0.1 of /e/ but nothing blocking. (- little problem with icons for example, now solved - problem to install “FreeFlight Pro”, now solved, etc)
One thing never worked on this device, it’s the weather on the page with search and suggestions. It never missed me, I prefer to look at the window.
When version 0.5 came out, some more serious problems arrived :
-
Crash of Bliss Launcher.
The problem was quickly solved by the team (thanks). Since I keep “Nova Launcher” installed, in case of. But Bliss is my default launcher ! -
Account manager don’t work anymore with my Baikal server, I had to install DAVx5 for workaround.
To date, the problem is still present. (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/wiki/en/issues/45) -
Calendar ask for Google account
To date, the problem is still present. (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/apps/Calendar/issues/6)
Some other problems are less important. (weather widget theme sometime change from transparent to dark, or cosmetic issues)
Now, I still have the Redmi Note 4 with version 0.5 and I planned to give a Pocophone F1 in my family. So I bought a new Pocophone F1.
First of all, I noticed that the weather on the page with search and suggestions is working on this device, I have weather forecasts without any intervention.
But unfortunately, I consider /e/ not usable in the state on Pocophone F1, I can’t give this to a non tech user in my family.
Too many blocking problems.
-
After a reboot, the date is 2009-01-01 1:00 (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/devices/xiaomi/proprietary_vendor_xiaomi/issues/3)
It blocks wifi, GSM, GPS, so no network at all. I have to set manually the date and time to have networks back… -
Status bar (and apps in general) is hidden by the “black notch” for cameras on the top, we lose informations. (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/management/issues/251)
-
Opencamera make very ugly pictures (but good videos) (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/management/issues/254)
Over people have that problem. (Xiaomi pocophone f1 camera app)
The workaround for this is to install an other camera app. I tested “Simple Camera” and the photos are good.
But Opencamera is knwon to be a good app, I would like to use it. -
Account manager don’t work with my Baikal server, and the workaround with DAVx5 don’t work on this device…
The only solution I have is to import .vcf files… (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/wiki/en/issues/45) -
Big issues with bluetooth. I can’t connect to my raspberry media server, I can’t connect to my Redmi Note 4.
Rarely I can connect to my PC but in this case, I can’t send files.
I can connect to my radio in car, but the calls are cut after about 14 seconds.
So the bluetooth is simply unusable.
Issue for calls in car. (https://gitlab.e.foundation/e/devices/xiaomi/proprietary_vendor_xiaomi/issues/4)
Other problems are less important, but present :
-
I always have annoying notifications like “Signal is using battery” or “Music is running in background”.
Ok, it comes with Oreo, but it’s boring.
As I was used to have a smartphone with Android 7 (the Redmi Note 4), maybe I’m not used to version 8 of Android enough. -
At upgrade procedure, in TWRP, there is a message “Unable to mount storage”. But it seems to make the update anyway…
Note on TWRP :
On both devices, I had problem to flash TWRP. In the procedure, after the “fastboot flash recovery twrp-x.x.x-x-mido.img”, if I reboot, the recovery was still the one from Xiaomi.
I had to make two “fastboot flash recovery twrp-x.x.x-x-mido.img” command in a row to have the recovery really flashed… strange. 8-/
In general, I would like to see improvements on Bliss, like :
- The possibility to place icons anywhere on the screen, not just all aligned.
- The possibility to modify app icons order in a submenu as I group games together or apps together.
Some apps comes with /e/ but is not needed for me, I used this procedure to remove the unwanted system apps. (in fact just Telegram.)
https://www.xda-developers.com/uninstall-carrier-oem-bloatware-without-root-access/
I didn’t test an e account, but maybe one day, I will ask for one to see what comes with it.
In conclusion,
I still use /e/ and I planned to use it in the future on my Redmi Note 4.
I’m not using /e/ on the Pocophone F1 as there is too many blocking problems. In fact I don’t use at all the Pocophone… just make the updates to see if problems are gone.
And I hope, these problems for the Pocophone F1 will be solved in future releases as I realy would like to use it with /e/.
I’m convinced that version 1.0 will be even better.
Many thanks for all the team of the project, keep going, it’s a great job !